Dry-Type Transformers vs. Oil-Immersed Transformers: How to Choose?


Published Time:

2026-11-11

In overseas projects involving distribution networks, photovoltaic and energy storage systems, data centers, subways, and industrial/commercial power distribution, electrical EPC contractors and procurement engineers often face the challenge of choosing between dry-type and oil-immersed transformers. Many clients focus solely on the initial purchase price while overlooking site conditions, fire safety regulations, maintenance requirements, and total cost of ownership, which can lead to retrofit work, safety hazards, or costly recurring maintenance expenses down the line. This article compares these two options across six dimensions—fire safety, maintenance complexity, applicable environments, upfront investment, long-term costs, and installation requirements—to help you quickly select the most suitable solution for your project.

1. Differences in Basic Operating Principles

The windings of dry-type transformers (cast resin type/dry-type transformers) are encapsulated using epoxy resin casting or vacuum pressure impregnation, without the use of liquid insulating media. Heat dissipation is achieved through natural air convection or forced air cooling. The SCB series epoxy resin cast dry-type transformers are currently the mainstream products on the market.

Oil-immersed transformers use mineral oil or natural ester oil as the insulating and cooling medium. The windings are fully immersed in insulating oil, and heat is removed by oil circulation. This is a mature and conventional solution widely used in distribution and step-up applications.

2. Fire and Explosion Prevention

The primary advantage of dry-type transformers is their fire safety. Because they do not use flammable liquid insulation, even in the event of internal insulation breakdown or localized overheating, ignition, oil spraying, or explosion is unlikely, and any resulting fire can be easily contained. Consequently, they are suitable for indoor locations, basements, data centers, subway substations, and areas with occupant activity. Most codes permit direct installation within buildings without the need for dedicated fire-rated partitions.

The insulating oil in oil-immersed transformers is flammable. If an internal short circuit occurs, there is a risk that oil will be ejected and ignite. Therefore, conventional mineral-oil transformers are typically located outdoors in separate enclosures and fitted with firewalls and oil containment pits. Indoor installation faces strict approval requirements; many overseas cities and commercial building fire codes expressly prohibit installing standard oil-immersed transformers inside buildings. Natural-ester insulating oils have higher flash points and lower fire risk, but they are still liquid dielectrics and cannot achieve the fire-safety level of dry-type transformers.

3. Maintenance Requirements

The main causes of failure in dry-type transformers include dust accumulation, blocked cooling ducts, condensation in humid environments, and resin cracking. Routine maintenance tasks include visual inspections, dust removal, infrared temperature measurements, and spot checks for partial discharge. Oil filtration or replacement is unnecessary, and there is no risk of oil leakage. In clean environments, maintenance intervals can be extended. A drawback is that, once severe internal insulation damage occurs, repair becomes difficult, often requiring replacement of the windings or the entire unit.

Oil-immersed transformers have a well-established maintenance regime. Oil samples must be taken regularly for dissolved gas analysis (DGA), breakdown voltage testing, and moisture content measurement. Sealing gaskets age over time, increasing the risk of oil leaks; therefore, seals, valves, and welds should be inspected periodically. On the positive side, oil chromatography can detect faults early, and most issues can be repaired in the manufacturer’s workshop at a lower cost than replacing an entire dry-type unit.

4. Application Boundaries by Environment

Dry-type transformers should be preferred for: Indoor substations, basements, data centers, rail transit facilities, manned factories, projects in Southeast Asian cities with stringent fire safety codes, and sites where space is limited and there is no room to install oil containment bunds. In areas with severe dust exposure, an additional protective enclosure must be provided.

Applications where oil-immersed transformers are preferred: Outdoor substations, large-scale photovoltaic step-up stations, remote mining areas, high-capacity distribution applications, and projects that are sensitive to upfront capital expenditures and can accommodate fire-isolation facilities. In high-humidity and salt-spray environments, reliable operation can be achieved through appropriate corrosion-protection and sealing designs.

5. Purchase Price and Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)

For transformers of the same capacity and energy efficiency class, dry-type transformers have a significantly higher unit purchase price. However, the quoted price does not equate to the total project cost. When factoring in the additional costs required for oil-immersed transformers—such as firewalls, emergency oil storage tanks, fire protection systems, and regular oil testing—the overall cost gap between the two becomes considerably narrower, especially in locations with limited indoor space. When making long-term plans, owners should assess the total cost of ownership (TCO) over the asset’s entire lifecycle, rather than simply comparing unit prices.

6. Quick Selection Comparison Table

 

Compare Items

Dry-type transformer

Oil-immersed transformer

Fire resistance rating

Excellent, non-flammable

Mineral oil: flammable; natural ester oil: low flammability

Installation Location

Suitable for both indoor and outdoor use, indoor-friendly.

Outdoor installation is preferred; indoor installation requires strict approval.

Scope of Maintenance

Dust removal, temperature measurement, partial discharge detection; oil-free maintenance

DGA testing, oil filtration, seal inspection, and oil leak remediation

Repairability

Difficult to repair after a severe failure

It can be repaired through a well-established early warning system.

Initial Capital Cost

Higher

Lower

Noise level

Slightly higher at the same capacity

Mature design enables low-noise operation.

7. Quick Decision-Making Guide

If the transformer is to be installed inside a building in an occupied area, and the local fire safety regulations are stringent such that fire-resistant separation measures cannot be implemented, a resin‑cast dry‑type transformer should be selected as the preferred option.

If the site is an open‑air PV/energy storage substation, a remote mining area, or a location that meets fire‑safety requirements and the goal is to minimize initial capital expenditure in high‑capacity step‑up applications, oil‑immersed transformers offer better value for money.